TRI-COUNTY REGIONAL PLANNING COMMISSION
IMPORTANCE OF EMERGING TECHNOLOGIES ––
A number of technologies have had a significant impact on the region’s transportation system since the last RTP update. For example:
smartphone technology has enabled Uber and other ridesharing applications to begin operating in the region;
Capital Area Transit and rabbittransit users can now track their bus locations on their smartphones;
adaptive traffic signal technology has improved the operation of some of our most congested corridors; and,
Global Positioning System (GPS) technologies are now widely available in cars and trucks, enabling drivers to more easily reach their destinations and deal with detours and other unexpected conditions.
Emerging technologies that improve safety and traffic flow -- most notably connected and autonomous vehicle technology (CV/AV) -- have the potential to substantially change how our transportation system operates within the RTP's planning period. For example:
trucks will regularly operate in connected “platoons";
urban transit vehicles will be driverless, and rural transit service will be demand-responsive; and,
automobiles will be highly autonomous and/or connected.
These developments could enable connected vehicles to travel much closer together, reducing driver distractions, accidents and injuries while also increasing existing roadway capacity.
These technologies are changing so rapidly, however, that it is impossible to predict their impact over a 20-year planning horizon. As an alternative to making predictions, this plan recognizes the technologies already impacting transportation in the region along with those expected to have the greatest potential impact in the near term.
This section of the plan will be updated regularly as new technologies emerge and their impacts are better understood.
ADAPTIVE TRAFFIC CONTROL SYSTEMS
(Source of material in quotes: Federal Highway Administration)
"Poor traffic signal timing contributes to traffic congestion and delay. Conventional signal systems use pre-programmed, daily signal timing schedules. Adaptive signal control technology adjusts the timing of red, yellow and green lights to accommodate changing traffic patterns and ease traffic congestion. The main benefits of adaptive signal control technology over conventional signal systems are that it can:
Continuously distribute green light time equitably for all traffic movements
Improve travel time reliability by progressively moving vehicles through green lights
Reduce congestion by creating smoother flow
Prolong the effectiveness of traffic signal timing . . .
Cameron & Market streets, Harrisburg
"The process is simple. First, traffic sensors collect data. Next, traffic data is evaluated and signal timing improvements are developed. Finally, ASCT implements signal timing updates. The process is repeated every few minutes to keep traffic flowing smoothly. On average ASCT improves travel time by more than 10 percent. In areas with particularly outdated signal timing, improvements can be 50 percent or more . . .
"Special events, construction, or traffic incidents typically wreak havoc on traffic conditions. While large-scale construction projects and regular events can be anticipated, determining their impact on traffic conditions can be extremely difficult. Other disruptions, such as crashes, are impossible for time-of-day signal timing to accommodate . . .
"Outdated traffic signal timing incurs substantial costs to businesses and consumers. They account for more than 10 percent of all traffic delay and congestion on major routes alone. For consumers, this causes excess delays and fuel consumption. For businesses, it decreases productivity and increases labor costs. According to the Texas Transportation Institute, the cost of traffic congestion is $87.2 billion in wasted fuel and lost productivity. That translates to $750 per traveler . . .
"Adaptive signal control technologies are also kinder to the environment. Using ASCT can reduce emissions of hydrocarbons and carbon monoxide due to improved traffic flow."
Adaptive signals have been installed within the HATS region in portions of the Carlisle Pike and Jonestown Road corridors. The charts below show the vehicle hours of delay, for both passenger and commercial vehicles, along the Carlisle Pike and Jonestown Road corridors where ASCT signalization is installed. The charts show data beginning in January 2014 and go until December 2019. The red lines in each chart note the approximate time period in which the adaptive signals went live.
HATS will review congestion along these corridors and other signalized corridors throughout the region as part of the upcoming Congestion Management Process update. As part of the upcoming CMP, HATS will continue to monitor congestion and delay on these two corridors to Adaptive signal control technology will be considered for other signalized corridors identified as highly congested as a possible means of reducing congestion without substantial infrastructure investments.
Carlisle Pike Vehicle Delay - Click for larger image
Jonestown Road Vehicle Delay - Click for larger image
Global Positioning System (GPS) technology is based on a number of government-owned satellites that allow for highly accurate positional information at any location on Earth. GPS mapping applications are now nearly universal in passenger vehicles, trucks, trains and aircraft as a directional aid that typically provides visual and audible directions to any designated location.
GPS technology has also facilitated a number of applications that provide directional guidance for users, in many cases providing specialized service like detour guidance for congestion, accidents and road closures. Examples include Google Maps, Waze and many others. Such applications are likely to become even more numerous and provide enhanced services throughout the planning period, thereby helping to reduce congestion.
However, directional GPS technologies have also led to problems with trucks in residential and rural areas because drivers are simply following the GPS directions. HATS plans to investigate the potential for working with GPS providers in identifying such constraints as vertical clearances and restricted bridges so trucks can be directed to the most appropriate routes.
GPS technology is also a critical component in the growth of microtransit services, such as rabbittransit’s Stop Hopper service, as well as other ridesharing applications like Uber and Lyft. Microtransit is an app-driven, demand responsive, zonal-based transit service currently used around Pennsylvania in fixed route first-and-last mile solutions and where fixed route transit service may not be viable, among others.
Several areas in the HATS planning region are being considered for microtransit service expansion. While private-sector Uber and Lyft services can be easily accessed in the urban and suburban portions of the planning area, they are not viable options in rural areas like northern Dauphin County, Perry County or western Cumberland County. These services may take advantage of driverless vehicle technology in urban areas in the future. HATS intends to track the expansion of microtransit and applications like Uber and Lyft to study their impact on overall traffic conditions and travel throughout the HATS region.
Today’s transit vehicles also take advantage of GPS technology through the FRITS (Fixed Route ITS) system being installed throughout the state.CAT buses are currently undergoing the upgrade to the new technology. Through the FRITS system information, automatic passenger counters (APCs) collect rider data by bus stop, and fixed route operations can track the location and operation of buses in service. Riders can track the location of their bus and estimated stop arrival times through the MyStop app. HATS intends to work with transit provider stop determine their usage and impact on overall ridership, potentially assisting in educational campaigns if it is determined that awareness of such technology increases transit ridership.
Air travel is also being enhanced through GPS technology. “FlightAware,” “FlightRadar 24,” “Trip Tracker” and many others enable users to verify the precise location of a specific aircraft and make plans in the event of delays, etc. Updates to flight schedules can be sent directly to smartphones, allowing for much more accurate passenger arrival and pickup times.
CONNECTED & AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
Automated or autonomous vehicles (AV) are cars, trucks or buses that take full control of all aspects of the dynamic driving task for at least some of the time. A connected vehicle (CV) has internal devices that connect it to other vehicles, as in vehicle-to-vehicle (V2V) communication, or a back-end infrastructure system as in vehicle-to-infrastructure (V2I) communication. V2V applications enable crash prevention and V2I applications enable telecommunication, safety, mobility and environmental benefits.
Implementing CV technology requires vehicles to be able to communicate, with "Dedicated short-range communication” (DSRC) currently being the leading medium for such applications. At present, V2V and V2I applications only provide driver alerts and do not control vehicle operation.
At TCRPC's May 2018 luncheon, national expert on automated and “connected” vehicles Matt Smith (left), of Michael Baker International, previewed what local governments and communities can expect when driverless cars and trucks take to the roads in the future.
As more vehicles become automated and connected, they have the potential to profoundly change personal, freight and public transportation. As producers sell AVs and CVs and consumers buy them, crashes, traffic congestion, air pollution and other impacts associated with travel may significantly diminish.
On the other hand, because technology can solve some problems and create new ones, AVs and CVs may have drawbacks and risks. For example, cybersecurity vulnerabilities associated with CVs could compromise safety. Also, congestion could increase with the proliferation of AVs as driving becomes less onerous and individuals who do not drive today have more opportunities for travel.
There is significant debate about the implementation rate for CV and AV technologies and their likely impacts. Given how quickly these technologies have grown, their impacts will certainly be felt long before this plan's 20-year horizon.
Given the potential of these technologies to significantly improve safety and reduce congestion on our roadways -- minimizing crashes, facilitating the movement of freight, reducing single occupancy travel through ridesharing and transit applications -- it is HATS' policy to facilitate their implementation.
As an initial step in a proactive approach, TCRPC led a study to assist PennDOT District 8’s planning partners and MPOs/RPOs across the Commonwealth with the implementation of DSRC technology. The study helped to define and discuss connected and autonomous vehicle technology, summarize DSRC V2I deployment impacts and priorities, and provide cost/design considerations for implementation. V2I technology has been deployed within 19 states, with Harrisburg and Pittsburgh having some V2I infrastructure deployed and Philadelphia in the process to install infrastructure throughout the city. The study completed in 2019 helps prioritize corridors and will help integrate MPO planning efforts into future TIPs. For more information regarding DSRC implementation, click here.
HATS' most appropriate roles at this point appear to be education/outreach relating to these technologies to reduce residents' fears associated with their use and in the deployment of DSRC technology as a means to facilitate the most rapidly deployed components of CV applications.
As such, HATS should meet periodically with PennDOT and other leaders in this field to explore educational opportunities and any financial commitments necessary to most effectively deploy DSRC (or related, as appropriate) technology.